Полуфинал Viewer's Choice Awards 2013

Chono написал(а):
Эх, а когда то русское комьюнити давало жару. Дружное было.
Слабые все стали =(

Хз-хз, бест драма, стори, романтик, сантиментал, фан, чарактер профиль, юз оф спешл эффектз, мост артистик, мост ориджинал, юз оф инструментал мьюзик, юз оф мультипл аниме, эдитор оф зе иар, мост импрувмент эдитор, видео оф зе иар - пока наиболее очевидны за русскоговорящими авторами или хотя бы имеют равные шансы с другими.
С экшн, МЕП, комеди и пароди уже точно ничего не светит. В остальных номах хз, но в принципе неплохо и так.

Эх, а когда то русское комьюнити давало жару. Дружное было.
Слабые все стали =(

goЯz написал(а):
and the friends choice awards goes to....? #fail

Nan mais allo quoi ? C'est la guerre mondiale de 78 !

Guess my previous post needs some correction. Although we clearly have rating manipulation problem, it was premature to blame the whole Rising Production of it when it can be traced to several persons only. So I apologise for accusing the whole studio and hope that Rising Production members shall solve this problem between themselves for good.

Dark_Death, I talked privately with Minstrel and in our studio we are currently discussing this thing to find who is the problem.

[key]Scarlet , It's true...you may have nothing to do with it, nor diegao94, but the fact remains one of your studio members is up to something. That wasn't something i made up on the spot, it was an observation over time...but it's beside the point now as the admin has confirmed my suspicions to be true.
Kyros is the only other really active person i see, so its logical to assume its one of the three

I don't lie saying that I have two accounts, this one and PrincessKairy (a nickname which I've abandoned long time ago).
Dark_Death, once you said "typical rising production video here...starts off in the evaluation...studio and friends vote for it to be on main....studio and friends rank it as 5 when its not even worth 5", like all our videos (mine included) are in the home page. Well actually I have only "Glorium" in it. Also, it has happened several times (I particularly remember my video ".DiE") that videos which could easly pass to the homepage, within ten minutes they passed from having 20 "for" and 10 "against" to 20 "for" and 40 "against". But this seems legit.
I could be a dickhead who likes flamming and because of this I have already enough haters, but I don't want to be involved in something i have nothing to do with.
If the other members have as many account as you said, I don't know anything about it and it's unfair involve all the studio when maybe there's only one nocive member and not all of us.

diegao94, I'd like to make some points as this site admin. While it's true that Rising Production has quite a few good videos, it's also true that here at AMVNews videos of this studio traditionally have one of the highest levels of rating manipulation - from 3-4 and up to 12-20 of "extra" votes per video, and usually from the same accounts over and over again. This is the case even for rather strong videos which can actually do well without any manipulations, so this kind of extra voting does more harm than good to your studio as it becomes exposed.

I keep track of all the accounts extra votes were posted from, so as of now I have enough reasons to ban some of these people for multi-accounting. Should also say that, watching this kind of situation at AMVNews, I'm not surprised much with VCA voting results. You may be a strong and unified studio with strong support in domestic and international community, but I had my chance to see that you use some pretty much unfair rules to play by.

Если взять во внимание все факты, то результат вполне ожидаемый. Конечно, можно найти пару курьезных моментов наподобие:
Best Multi-Editor Project (Shin-AMV (Shin ) - A-M-V.org Viewer's Choice Awards – Finalists - которое по сути склейка из финалистов прошлого года. Исключительно для привлечения внимания. И не надеясь пройти в полу финал, но вот оно перед нами. Уверен можно также найти чего-то в таком духе.

Dark_Death, I can see your point. That is an extremely weird situation, but we have nothing to do with it. I'm not a liar, I can easly tell you that I also voted for my friends, but only for the few I thought deserved at least the semi-finals. And we are not that kind of idiots who vote for ourselves and especially for all our videos. We are currently shocked of all those our videos in the semifinals, which obviously don't deserve it. I don't give a fuck about having all my videos or all my studio mates videos in the semifinals or in the finals, if we don't deserve it. But the biggest shame is that our videos which deserved the semi-finals are now degraded to the others which didn't, and this made me angry. I don't know how they managed to be there, maybe for the same reason we often start from exam and then we are brought to the main page with the viewers votes in this site. Cause that's it, there are people who like our videos, and in fact you can see that we still have a pretty nice average vote in the main page, and there are several positive comments. Maybe it's just you that have a problem against us.
However, if they are unworthy videos, they won't surely be in the finals.

There are also other things that I didn't like in these semifinals, for example Affective Schoolgirls which is not in the Best Action category while it's clearly the true winner.

goЯz написал(а):
and the friends choice awards goes to....? #fail

Rising Production is the problem, you can see it on amvnews as well..there videos almost always enter the exam section, yet somehow end up with almost 50 votes for transfer to main . VCA yet again shows this, a studio pushing there own agenda at the expense of fair play.

Like a cancer to the amv community these people, basically cheating when there is no reason to.

Зюся в хорроры не попал :(
А, так он и не добавлял свой клип туда

Personally I'm disappointed this year. I dunno how is this going to end but

Лол, в ному "Лучший клип года" ГиКи прошли не с тем клипом, а Отохико вообще пролетел как фанера над парижем, будто и не модер там вообще, ну и Робче, Селиафэль и МистериозРайдер чё-то тоже не хватает. Зато [key]Scarlet как-то пропихнули с вазелином и ни его одного. Хотя... Мы ведь всё равно все знаем кто в этой номе победит, так что грех жаловаться.

Friends Choice Awards традиционно уничтожает здравый смысл

redbull написал(а):
неужели местные "друзяшки" - такая прям сила?

Нет, конечно. Просто они за 3 дня делают круче, чем наши за недели и месяцы. :D

нда, чуть ли не 2/3 клипов в полуфиналах - какие-то айрончифовские поделки. неужели местные "друзяшки" - такая прям сила?

and the friends choice awards goes to....? #fail

The whole nomination system on that website is flawed, half of the videos are not what "viewers" truly think at all. It's biased to friends voting for friends, which is sad and makes the whole thing a sham.

Even the youtube can see that https://twitter.com/BestAMVs/status/310368475015155714 , French probably thinking the same

Best single source is a good example for the whole sham as well, no Affective Schoolgirls or Orion to name two, yet there are 13 Rising Production videos nominated....are you kidding me? viewers definitely like those videos, but they are to busy voting for friends only....

Personally, saw no GLORY OR Affective Schoolgirls in best action so didn't check the rest.

Ситуация с процентом иностранных клипов в финалах могла быть получше, если бы у нас народу на орге было не полтора дровосека.

Подозрительно мало номинаций включают Affective Schoolgirls, особенно близких к нему тематически(