Behelit

Here to remind you that creating multiple accounts to manipulate voting is a bad idea that usually ends with a ban.

wow SeNnin still alive interesting combo
p.s your Sullen best

This clip makes interested looks Guts and Griffith history, and this music creatures original composition for this MV content. Although i have found, the exist one serious problem: i don't sense screams of thunder in this melody. This music is very light emotional coloring, that does not allow it successfully mirrored hard and dramatic atmospheare world of four angels and Guts, fighting against them. If author really wish show "thunder", this track not exactly that, does might find successful result. I think so.

SeNniN написал(а):


Lyrics is what sets up the song not just music alone. Of course, you won't understand the connection with music alone. This isn't meant to be a instrument amv it's heavily based on lyrics for the most part.

Не согласен, текст - это текст, он может быть историей, стихом или песней, если это песня, то зависит от тональности, мотива и т.д.
Есть много примеров, например каверы на старые песни. Мы можем спорить достаточно долго, но как для меня это аргумент при создании amv.

Necoma написал(а):

Как по мне важен не только смысл, тут бы изминить музыкальное сопровождение. Скорее всего проблема в настроении которое задает мелодия, а не песня.

Lyrics is what sets up the song not just music alone. Of course, you won't understand the connection with music alone. This isn't meant to be a instrument amv it's heavily based on lyrics for the most part.

SeNniN написал(а):


It's a character profile on Griffith. The song if you listen to the lyrics does fit to his character. I think that's the issue, most people didn't understand the song.

Как по мне важен не только смысл, тут бы изминить музыкальное сопровождение. Скорее всего проблема в настроении которое задает мелодия, а не песня.

Strannick610 написал(а):
М/В вообще мимо, под дарк-фэнтези аниме старой школы не ложится такая попсовая песенка. С таким же успехом под условный Властелин Колец можно пустить Верку Сердючку.

It's a character profile on Griffith. The song if you listen to the lyrics does fit to his character. I think that's the issue, most people didn't understand the song.

М/В вообще мимо, под дарк-фэнтези аниме старой школы не ложится такая попсовая песенка. С таким же успехом под условный Властелин Колец можно пустить Верку Сердючку.

Goliard написал(а):

Well, maybe there is indeed, although misunderstanding happen even between native speakers.

True. Your English is perfectly fine, I'm just referring to the fact that my comment could have been taken the wrong way.
Thank you for your feedback bro!

SeNniN написал(а):
I think there is a language barrier here, you're taking it the wrong way.

Well, maybe there is indeed, although misunderstanding happen even between native speakers.

Goliard написал(а):

I understand you think you're very special, but you are not the only one who thinks about s\s (song\source combination) and scene selection. People will not respect you just because of some thoughts you've made about s\s. They will respect you if they like the result, not because of your efforts, see? People give high grades only for effort if there are some difficult vfx or something like that.
Secondly, I didn't say there is no thought process. I said I don't like cutting rhythm.

I think there is a language barrier here, you're taking it the wrong way. Don't worry about it bud, its okay I know exactly what you said.

SeNniN написал(а):
That's all, you don't think there is any thought process in scene selection and audio/source combination. Interesting perspective.

I understand you think you're very special, but you are not the only one who thinks about s\s (song\source combination) and scene selection. People will not respect you just because of some thoughts you've made about s\s. They will respect you if they like the result, not because of your efforts, see? People give high grades only for effort if there are some difficult vfx or something like that.
Secondly, I didn't say there is no thought process. I said I don't like cutting rhythm.

Goliard написал(а):

*shrugging*
Certainly some videos on main are not so well-made, but on the other hand there is works on exam that is better than yours (in my opinion), for example: Depravity

I myself don't like cutting rhythm.

That's a very different amv. lol.. cutting to rhythm? That's all, you don't think there is any thought process in scene selection and audio/source combination. Interesting perspective.
I see where this is coming from then I got it fam. :]

SeNniN написал(а):
You think it deserves it?

*shrugging*
Certainly some videos on main are not so well-made, but on the other hand there is works on exam that is better than yours (in my opinion), for example: Depravity

I myself don't like cutting rhythm.

Goliard написал(а):
SeNniN, the voting is not over yet. You can't see the vote form because you're uploader.
But answering to your question, I'm not surprised the video (still) didn't make it to the Main.

I've been here since 2010 lol I know the voting system. I'm not trying to be arrogant but I honestly don't know their disqualify criteria for exam. You think it deserves it? Would love to hear your thoughts feel free to highlight your reasons.

SeNniN, the voting is not over yet. You can't see the vote form because you're uploader.
But answering to your question, I'm not surprised the video (still) didn't make it to the Main.

This deserves exam? Are you serious?